|
22-001
|
Is the Paradise Valley local ordinance on short term rentals in conflict with existing state law?
Complaint Form
Paradise Valley Ordinance
Response Request
Response from Town of Paradise Valley
Report
FINAL DISPOSITION: VIOLATES STATE LAW IN PART (ORDINANCE AMENDED BY TOWN OF PARADISE VALLEY)
|
Sen. Warren Petersen |
|
|
|
|
21-006
|
Whether Pima County memorandum titled: FAQs Regarding Mandatory Vaccinations for New Hires Promotions and Employees Working with Vulnerable Populations violates ARS 23-206 & Executive Order 2021-18
Complaint Form
FAQs For New Hires
Process for Off-Boarding Unvaccinated Staff
Response Request
Pima County Response Letter
FINAL DISPOSITION: WITHDRAWN BY REQUESTING LEGISLATOR
|
Sen. Kelly Townsend |
|
|
|
|
21-005
|
Whether Tucson Administrative Directive 2.03-7 violates A.R.S. § 23-206?
Complaint Form
Tucson Administrative Directive 2.03-7
Response Letter
FINAL DISPOSITION: WITHDRAWN BY REQUESTING LEGISLATOR
|
Sen. Kelly Townsend |
|
|
|
|
21-004
|
Whether Tucson Administrative Directive 2.03-7 violates A.R.S. § 23-206?
Complaint Form
Response Request
Tucson Response Letter
FINAL DISPOSITION: WITHDRAWN BY REQUESTING LEGISLATOR
|
Sen. Vince Leach |
|
|
|
|
21-003
|
Whether Tucson Ordinance 11869 (requiring employees to receive a COVID vaccination as a term of employment) violates Executive Order 2021-18, A.R.S. 36-787, A.R.S. 36-114, A.R.S. 36-681, A.R.S. 36-184.
Complaint Form
Ordinance 11869
Tucson Response Request
Tucson Response
Tucson Report
FINAL DISPOSITION: VIOLATES STATE LAW
|
Sen. Kelly Townsend |
|
|
|
|
21-002
|
Whether MCBOS violated ARS 41-1151, 41-1153, 41-1154, and/or 16-624.
Complaint Form
MCBOS Response Request
MCBOS Response
MCBOS Report
FINAL DISPOSITION: VIOLATES STATE LAW
|
Sen. Sonny Borrelli |
|
|
|
|
21-001
|
Whether a moratorium on eviction proceedings adopted by the Pima County Board of Supervisors violates the Arizona Constitution and/or state statutes.
Complaint Form
Complaint Letter
Complaint Response Request
Response from Pima County Board of Supervisors
Complaint Closing Letter
FINAL DISPOSITION: INVESTIGATION MOOT (MORATORIUM REPEALED BY PIMA COUNTY)
|
Sen. Vince Leach, Rep. Bret Roberts |
|
|
|
|
20-002
|
Following a significant decrease in voter turnout at the 2019 Tucson city election compared to the 2018 statewide election, does Tucson city ordinance 11731 violate A.R.S. 16-204.01 by calling for elections for city council, as well as for city ballot measures, to continue to be held off cycle in 2021 rather than on the statewide election dates in 2022?
Letter to City of Tucson - Notice and Request for Response
City of Tucson Response
Exhibit A
Final Report
AZ Supreme Court Ruling – State of Arizona v. Tucson
FINAL DISPOSITION: MAY VIOLATE STATE LAW (UPHELD AT ARIZONA SUPREME COURT)
|
Sen. J.D. Mesnard |
|
|
|
|
20-001
|
Whether the May 13, 2020, Proclamation of the Pima County Board of Supervisors violates A.R.S. § 26-307, in light of Governor Ducey’s Executive Order 2020-36, ¶ 7
1487 Letter to Pima County
Pima County BOS Memo
Pima County BOS Notice
Pima County Health Dept Email
Executive Order 2020-36
Exhibit 1
Exhibit 2
Exhibit 3
Exhibit 4
Exhibit 5
Exhibit 6
1487 Response Letter
Closing Letter
FINAL DISPOSITION: INVESTIGATION MOOT (PROCLAMATION REPEALED BY PIMA COUNTY)
|
Sen. Vince Leach, Rep. Mark Finchem, Rep. Bret Roberts |
|
|
|
|
19-002
|
Whether City of Phoenix Ordinance G-6650 violates Article IX, Section 25 of the Arizona Constitution.
Attachment A
Ordinance G6650
Response of the City of Phoenix Regarding Investigation of Complaint by Rep. Barto Under ARS 41-194.01
Exhibits 1-9
Final Report
ASC Order Finding Ordinance Constitutional - 04/02/2020
ASC Order Granting Stipulated Motion - 04/20/2020
FINAL DISPOSITION: MAY VIOLATE STATE LAW (ORDINANCE UPHELD BY ARIZONA SUPREME COURT)
|
Rep. Nancy Barto |
|
|
|
|
19-001
|
Whether the City of Tempe Ordinance 01017.51 violates ARS 16-905(E)?
Final Report
FINAL DISPOSITION: DOES NOT VIOLATE STATE LAW
|
Sen. Vince Leach |
|
|
|
|
18-004
|
Whether Sedona's bed tax and agreement with the Chamber of Commerce violates the Gift Clause of the Arizona Constitution?
FINAL DISPOSITION: WITHDRAWN
|
Sen. Judy Burges |
|
|
|
| 18-003 |
Does Sedona Ordinance 2016-06, which requires business licenses for “transient rentals” but not for long-term rentals, violate A.R.S. § 9-500.39?
AG Signed Report RE: 18-003
FINAL DISPOSITION: VIOLATES STATE LAW (ORDINANCE REPEALED BY SEDONA)
|
Rep. Darin Mitchell |
|
|
|
| 18-002 |
Does Mohave County's unwritten policy of requiring an Animal Control inspection of private residences where the person applying for a "Limited Residential Animal Permit" per county zoning ordinance for 10 dogs and 10 cats as personal pet violate ARS §11-1604?
FINAL DISPOSITION: WITHDRAWN BY REQUESTING LEGISLATOR
|
Sen. Sonny Borrelli |
|
|
|
| 18-001 |
Whether the City of Tempe, through its ordinances and leases, is violating Arizona statutory restrictions on the use of Government Property Lease Excise Taxes
Attachment 1 – Tempe Ordinance No. 2017.39
Attachment 2 – Tempe Council Minutes – July 27, 2017
Attachment 3 – Tempe Ordinance No. 2017.48
Attachment 4 – Tempe Council Minutes – November 9, 2017
Attachment 5 – Tempe Resolution No. 2010.76
Attachment 6 – Tempe Staff Summary Report on Resolution No. 2010.76
Attachment 7 – Tempe Council Minutes – May 20, 2010
Attachment 8 – Graduate Tempe, LLC Lease
Attachment 9 – KBSII Fountainhead, LLC Lease
Attachment 10 – Leach Letter to City of Tempe dated November 30, 2017
AG Signed Report RE: 18-001
FINAL DISPOSITION: MAY VIOLATE STATE LAW (ORDINANCE AMENDED BY TEMPE)
|
Rep. Vince Leach |
|
|
|
| 17-005 |
Did the Town of Patagonia violate Arizona law by adopting an ordinance restricting the total number of trips made by a “heavy duty truck?
AG Signed Report RE: 17-005
FINAL DISPOSITION: DOES NOT VIOLATE STATE LAW
|
Rep. Vince Leach |
|
|
|
| 17-004 |
Whether the City of Phoenix Police Department's "Transparency Policy" violates A.R.S. 38-1109?
Attachment 1
AG Signed Report RE: Request No. 17-004
FINAL DISPOSITION: DOES NOT VIOLATE STATE LAW
|
Rep. Jay Lawrence |
|
|
|
| 17-003 |
Does the City of Bisbee's ordinance regulating the use of plastic bags violate state law?
AG Signed Report RE: Request No. 17-003
FINAL DISPOSITION: VIOLATES STATE LAW (ORDINANCE REPEALED BY BISBEE)
|
Sen. Warren Peterson |
|
|
|
| 17-002 |
Did the City of Phoenix violate state law when they enacted Phoenix Police Department Operations Order 4.48:Immigration Procedures?
Attachment 1 - Detailed Complaint
Attachment 2 - ARS 11-1051
Attachment 3 - Phoenix Police Operations Order 4.48 - Immigration Procedures
AG Signed Report RE: Request No. 17-002
FINAL DISPOSITION: DOES NOT VIOLATE STATE LAW
|
Sen. John Kavanagh |
|
|
|
| 17-001 |
Whether the City of Somerton's Ordinance requiring of a church a Conditional Use Permit to operate in a commercial zone is in conflict with Arizona law?
AG Letter to City of Somerton - August 10, 2017
City of Somerton Letter to AG - August 17, 2017
City of Somerton Letter to AG - August 28, 2017
FINAL DISPOSITION: WITHDRAWN BY REQUESTING LEGISLATOR (ORDINANCE REPEALED BY SUMMERTON)
|
Rep. Don Shooter |
|
|
|
| 16-002 |
Whether the City of Tucson is destroying confiscated and/or forfeited firearms in violation of Arizona law?
Attachment 1
Attachment 2
AG Signed Report RE: Request No. 16-002
Special Action to Repeal Tucson Gun Ordinance
AZ Supreme Court Ruling - State of Arizona v. City of Tucson
FINAL DISPOSITION: MAY VIOLATE STATE LAW (ORDINANCE REPEALED BY TUCSON)
|
Rep. Mark Finchem |
|
|
|
| 16-001 |
Has the Town of Snowflake violated provisions of state law with respect to the Approval of Facilities Agreement with, and special use permit to, Copperstate Farms LLC by the Snowflake Town Council on June 28, 2016?
AG Signed Report RE: Request No. 16-001
AG Letter to Rep. Paul Boyer - November 1, 2016
FINAL DISPOSITION: MAY VIOLATE STATE LAW (ORDINANCE REPEALED BY SNOWFLAKE)
|
Rep. Paul Boyer
|
